Most of you have heard people say how easy teachers have it because most do not work in the summer, but can you image the grief the teachers in Hawaii are getting for voting in favor of a four day work week? I can’t. The teachers union in Hawaii recently passed with 81% in favor of shorting the school year to 163 days, instead of the regular 180.
The reason for this school day shortage is money. Big surprise! The economy is hurting Hawaii which according the AP, “More than a quarter of the state's general budget goes to the state Department of Education”. The governor, “withheld 14% from estimated salaries, or $227 million,” the article from USA Today stated.
The teachers union, “ probably wouldn't have voted for the contract if they had to work the same amount for less pay, paving the way for the shorter school year, said Hawaii State Teachers Association President Wil Okabe. He also said the state couldn't get the necessary savings if teacher furlough days were scheduled for holidays — or workdays with schools kept open. By accepting the shorten days the teachers also accepted concurrent pay reduction and postponed layoffs and random drug testing for two years.
So my first question to my classmates is, “would you have voted in favor of this?”
It is a very tough call because you have a feed yourself and your family. Nobody wants to be laid off and no one wants to take a pay cut. I can’t image being put in a situation like this. On one hand you are thinking of yourself and on the other you are thinking of the educational opportunities the students will be missing by the shorten school year.
Students and parents in Hawaii are voicing their thoughts on the issues. "It's just not enough time for the kids to learn," said Valerie Sonoda, president of the Hawaii State Parent Teacher Student Association. "I'm getting hundreds of calls and e-mails. They all have the same underlying concern, and that is the educational hours of the kids." The article does mention that some parents concerns were along the lines of not finding daycare for younger children and parents of special needs children not finding the proper services.
The state Hawaii has some other problems that many of you are familiar with, the No Child Left Behind Act. The Act set standards that states must meet in order to continue to receive federal funding. Hawaii is, “already ranked 47th in the nation in eighth-grade reading and math, according to 2007 National Assessment of Educational Progress test scores.” This is a real problem and by cutting more learning time how can Hawaii ever catch-up to other states? It won’t and might fall to last place which might take years or decades to recover from.
Since Hawaii is all one district the chance that this problem will go away is limited. I think the state is doing what it thinks is best for the budget, so we don’t have another California on our hands. I think the teachers are taking cuts to keep their jobs. What I wonder is what is the federal government doing? We are being pushed to nationalize healthcare which will cost at some estimates $860 billion dollars but the federal government isn’t concerned that the young people will be missing out on an education. Ironic, since Hawaii is the President’s home state don’t you think?
I am not taking a political jab, I am frustrated becasue students are going to suffer and some tend to have no problem bailing out GM or investors, then why not give the state short term loans to keep the schools open?
Why restructure? Does it really do anything?
-
Restructuring Under NCLB Found Not to Really Do Much
This week's final post comes in under the NCLB act. As you know from
previous posts, I am very pessimi...
15 years ago
Sounds like the teachers didn't have much of a choice when it came to voting for a shorter week. If they didn't vote for it, than the chance of losing their job was in jeopardy. This is a dilemma from a Federal standpoint and the government needs to step in and help out. Teachers can only do so much and this is out of their hands. This goes beyond the state of Hawaii and into governmental hands. I am with you on how the president needs to step it up and figure out a solution on this nationwide problem. And it shouldn't take months or years to help out by donating money when the problem is now.
ReplyDeleteKyren,
ReplyDeleteQuite honestly, I would not have voted for the shortened week. I'm in favor of year-round and/or longer days. I think Hawaii really needs to look at what they are doing to their students. Not only are they falling behind but they are only endorsing the idea that people who live on the beach (granted not all of Hawaii is a beach), don't have much intelligence because they are just "having fun in the sun."
I understand that the teachers were put in a position that they were between a rock and a hard spot, but this is where our Federal Government needs to step in. It seems to me that the Federal Government is putting all the responsibility on the shoulders of the teachers but isn't giving them the support they need to do their jobs. It's so frustrating to me!
Denise and Kim,
ReplyDeleteThanks for your comments and I hope the government steps in on this for the sake of the students.
Kyren,
ReplyDeleteWe had this come up at our small district this year. We thought about how much it would benefit the district actually. The instructional minutes would not be lost if the 4 days were increased and the 5th day was cut. It would have saved our district hundreds of thousands in transportation, food, and material costs to spare one day a week from teaching. The teachers wouldn't have to be paid less because the days would be longer and the kids wouldn't be shorted information or instructional minutes. In the end, we didn't do it. Instead our administration cut teacher jobs and increased our class sizes from 22 to 37 across the board in the middle school. It's not an improvement either.
The way it sounds in Hawaii, they didn't extend the school day. Maybe everyone rides a bike to school there, but not likely. The savings by cutting teacher pay will be massive. The cost of living in Hawaii is not going to help anyone stay there I bet unless that comes down, too. It is ironic that the first state to do exactly the opposite of what Obama wants is his home state. I wonder why this isn't all over the media?
Have a good weekend.
Randy B.
Thanks Randy for your comments. I guess the media is to worried about what the movie stars are doing then the children of this nation.
ReplyDeleteKyren,
ReplyDeleteThis is an issue that has been brought up in our district the past couple of years because something pretty similar has been successful in communities around Montana. Lincoln, Montana went to four, nine hour school days. School staff salaries are the same and students are getting the same amount of classroom time. The difference comes in transportation and utilities costs. I could only imagine what one less day of having buses running in my town would save the district. Kids would be ecstatic because they would only have three day weekends! I think there are close to 70 buses that run twice per day. Fuel and staff costs have to be pretty significant for only one day. Over the course of the year that would add up. Now in Hawaii it sounds like they did not extend the school day and I think that is a terrible idea and I am with Randy here when I question why this has not been made national news. If they are 47th in the union in 8th grade reading and math, taking 7 school hours away per week will only make that worse. Sad sad sad. Hard for me to feel too bad though...they live on the beach. It snowed here today. Seriously.
cheers,
ct
Kyren,
ReplyDeleteThis has been a hot topic in my state for the past three years. Cutting cost of the school day is at the forefront of the education departments priorities. Four day school weeks were proposed as well as an hours increase in the school day. Students would have the same time in the school building but instead of eight to four Monday through Friday the students would go eight to six Monday through Thursday. There are positives and negatives to the idea but I would prefer the four day week. I would not spend as much on gas and I would love a three day weekend. I can understand the negatives because there would be pay cuts for some school employees and babysitting issues for parents. There has to be a happy medium somewhere... Good Article
Blaire