I figured since my last blog was about middle school I better talk about higher education this week. The current economic downturn in the United States has caused many American families to rethink sending Jonny and Sally to college right now. This in turn has caused a financial shortfall for many community colleges.
Some community colleges are going as far as Vietnam to recruit students to help bring the money in for their institution. According to a USA Today article, “about 23 U.S. schools participating in last year's Asian recruitment tour organized by the American Association of Community Colleges.”
Why do you ask are they visiting a communist country? It is simple. The middle class in this Southeast Asia country is growing. The country of Vietnam is roughly of the twice the size of Arizona and, “more than 5,000” visas are issued to students that attend two-year colleges. If that doesn’t entice a recruiter to travel half way across the world nothing will.
So the question I am posing is should U.S. recruit foreign students?
In my opinion there are two major issues. One, are American students losing tuition scholarships and housing on campus to foreign students? Second, if colleges stop recruiting outside the U.S. does the diversity experience of college life lesson?
First, there is no evidence that indicates that housing is being loss to foreign students and even though colleges do provide scholarships the economic impact that, “International students contribute more than $15.5 billion in tuition and living expenses to the U.S. economy, through their expenditures on tuition and living expenses, making U.S higher education one of the country's largest service-sector exports”.
From my own experience the Millennials would rather live at home if they can and as far as scholarships go our community college has had trouble giving money away because students won’t take the time to fill out a simple one page form. It drives me crazy. I even make copies of easy $500 general scholarships to my students and get this; many say they don’t care, “because mom and dad are paying for it.”
My second question, concerning the learning of diversity at college and does it lessen the experience with few foreigners there. According to Patricia Gurin’s, “Students come to universities at a critical stage of their development--a time during which they define themselves in relation to others and experiment with different social roles before making permanent commitments to occupations, social groups, and intimate personal relationships”. She goes to state, “In addition, for many students college is the first sustained exposure to an environment other than their home communities”.
I tried to find some information on colleges or a student body that might be against foreign exchange students and couldn’t find any facts. I have heard rumors that some student body governments complained that colleges were losing their identity but I couldn’t find the details for sure.
I am in favor of colleges recruiting foreign students to study abroad because it sends a positive message of the United States and democracy back with them to their home countries. It also brings money into the U.S. which allows faculty and staff to have jobs. Lastly, it gives American students the opportunity to visit with other students and learn things about their cultural differences.
On a side note, I should mention that background checks for visas are extremely tough to get for the U.S. since 9/11. This should make us feel a bit safer that the State Department isn’t just handing them out.
Why restructure? Does it really do anything?
-
Restructuring Under NCLB Found Not to Really Do Much
This week's final post comes in under the NCLB act. As you know from
previous posts, I am very pessimi...
15 years ago
Kyren,
ReplyDeleteI found your blog very interesting. I hadn't thought about the foreign exchange student aspect of college life before.
You raise some interesting questions. I do think that American students, in general, are lazier than foreign students because they don't want to take the time to fill out the paperwork to se if they can get "free" money. To them, it's free money if their parents dish it out.
I've noticed that people, overall, don't have a sense of responsibility. Where does that come from? I wonder if some of it comes from the "helicopter" parents? We are doing our students and children a grave disservice.
I personal believe that it is a great opportunity to learn about other cultures and become more accepting of diversity if we allow students to come from other countries. But . . . somehow we need to motivate our own students. How? I don't know.
Thanks for sharing!
Kimberly
Thanks Kim for your thoughts. Like you, I have thought about what motivates my students, points, games, or money? I noticed more are driven when I can tie my lesson to a job task they might perform in the "read world". I think the economy going south has also motivated some to rethink the idea of skipping class.
ReplyDeleteKyren,
ReplyDeleteThis is a great topic and one that bears a great amount of discussion. My problem with universities recruiting out of the country is that they could be using those recruiting dollars here in the United States for various expenditures. Schools claim to be hurting (although I am having a tough time really believing that) so why not save overseas recruitment money and spend it on utilities, professor salaries or more scholarships for local kids? There has to be cost-effective ways to recruit overseas (such as on the internet or mailers) that universities can utilize. It makes me wonder how much overseas recruiting was being done when I was in college because there were TONS of Asians and European students at my college (if there wasn't, what foreign student would choose to come to Montana State University?). It was great to have them at the campus because they brought a whole new perspective to classes and exposed students to a different world outside of Montana. It is a tricky subject indeed in that do the positives of overseas recruitment outweigh the negatives? I am not sure if I can answer that.
cheers,
ct